A creed is a short statement of what the church believes together. If you recite the Apostles' Creed in worship and then see another church read the Nicene Creed, you may wonder which is more accurate. Both confess God, Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit, the church, and resurrection, but they arose in different settings and emphasize different questions.
Key point The Apostles' Creed took shape through baptism and instruction in the faith in the Western church. The Nicene Creed developed through fourth-century council discussions that sought, among other things, to confess clearly the relationship between Jesus Christ and God. Neither is an official abridgment of the other or a higher-level version, and denominations use them in different ways.
What to remember
- The Apostles' Creed is unlikely to be a document written one line at a time by each of the twelve apostles.
- The confession now called the Nicene Creed began at the council of 325 and went through a process of reception in 381 and afterward.
- When comparing the two creeds, look beyond their length and notice what each emphasizes in its statements about Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit.
Where do the two texts differ?
The Constitution of the Presbyterian Church of Korea (TongHap) includes both the Apostles' Creed and the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed. The Apostles' Creed briefly states Jesus' birth, suffering, death on the cross, and resurrection in sequence. The Nicene Creed more fully develops the confession that the Son is truly God and not a created being, as well as the confession about the Holy Spirit.
One developed in baptismal instruction, the other in a council
The Apostles' Creed is the result of the long shaping of the Western church's baptismal confession and question-and-answer faith instruction. The Nicene Creed began with the confession of the Council of Nicaea in 325 and later went through a process of acceptance in 381 and afterward.
The World Council of Churches describes the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed in current use as an expansion of the 325 creed.
Why the Nicene Creed is longer
Research on the history of the Nicene Creed distinguishes between the council text of 325 and the text used in worship today. The wording became more detailed as it responded to debates over whether Jesus is truly God and how the Holy Spirit should be confessed. The full text we use today was not completed in a single council.
How to read the two creeds side by side
The Apostles' Creed presents Jesus' life, death, and resurrection in a relatively brief sequence. In the Nicene Creed, you can examine in more detail how Jesus Christ's relationship to God is confessed and how the Holy Spirit is described. This is a way to study the two together, not a basis for ranking their value.
For example, if your order of worship includes only the Apostles' Creed, find the Nicene Creed separately and place statements on the same subject side by side. Mark how each statement answers the question, 'Who is Jesus?' This will reveal differences that go beyond sentence length. To know which creed should actually be used in worship, consult that church's tradition and rules.
Notes Comparing the Two Creeds
Place statements about the same topics from the Apostles' Creed and the Nicene Creed side by side.
What you enter is not sent to a server. If you save it, it will remain in this browser and be loaded automatically on your next visit. Content you copy or download may remain on your clipboard or in files. On a shared device, do not save, copy, or download your entries. Do not enter your real name, contact details, health information, personal confessions, or details of harm you have experienced.
Write down what the two creeds say in common about God and Jesus.
Write down where you notice differences in how the creeds speak about Jesus Christ or the Holy Spirit.
What would you like to ask about the translation your church uses or the creed it has adopted for worship?
After reading the creeds side by side, which differences in emphasis surprised you?
Notes
- The Filioque question, concerning whether to confess that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son, requires separate treatment when examining differences between Eastern and Western churches.
- The creed and Korean translation used in worship may differ by denomination.
References
- Scope of application
- This article does not cover the full political background of the councils, the Filioque controversy, or the history of reception in the Eastern and Western churches.
- The Presbyterian Church of Korea (TongHap) General Assembly Constitution, Part 1 Doctrine: Apostles' Creed and Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed
- Church of England Faith and Order Commission: GS Misc 1406
- World Council of Churches: Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed
- Ecclesiastical Law Journal: What did the Nicene Creed say?