When someone seems to be struggling, you may want to do something for them immediately. But unwanted help or sharing their story without permission can create another burden. To turn good intentions into real help, listen to the person first.

Key point Begin by asking, 'Is there something I can help you with?' Agree to help in a way the person wants and that you can actually provide. If the situation is dangerous or too difficult to handle alone, connect the person with a responsible individual or organization. Respect the choices and privacy of the person receiving help as well.

What to remember

  • Unless the situation is urgent, first ask whether help is wanted and respect the freedom to decline.
  • After checking what help the person wants and the time and money you can actually give, make a specific promise.
  • Do not share photographs or personal circumstances without permission, and do not demand a relationship or religious participation in return for help.
  • When safety is at risk or professional care is needed, do not try to handle the situation alone. Seek appropriate support.

The Good Samaritan came near and gave practical care

In Luke 10, the Samaritan who saw the person attacked by bandits did not pass by. He treated the wounds, put the person on his own animal and took them to an inn, and also took responsibility for the costs. Jesus shifts the original question, "Who is my neighbor?" to "Who became a neighbor?"

In the passage, the Samaritan cares for the one who needs help without first measuring their relationship to himself, and he invests not only words but also time and resources.

Ask first and choose help the person has agreed to

The story of the Good Samaritan shows an attitude that does not pass by a neighbor, but it is not a modern first-aid protocol. Unless the person is in immediate danger, ask, 'Is there something I can help you with?' If the person does not want help, stop.

If the person wants help, let them choose whether you bring something, help contact someone, or stay nearby for a while. Do not touch the person first, make decisions on their behalf, or question them about private matters in front of others.

As a hypothetical example, suppose a friend needs help paying for school meals. Instead of handing over something you used, ask what help they need. With their consent, you could connect them with a trustworthy staff member at school. If you promise to help, state clearly what you can do and by when.

If you record the help or tell others about it, explain why you want to disclose the person's name, photograph, or circumstances and obtain permission. Do not demand an expression of gratitude.

Do not discriminate, and do not stop at words

James 2 rebukes treating people with discrimination by giving the good place to the rich while telling the poor person to stand or sit in a low place. It then asks what good is done by only speaking to brothers and sisters who need food and clothing, but not giving them what they need for their bodies.

Connect needs that are too difficult to handle alone

If help requires a large expense or long-term care, explain how much time and money you can provide. After discussing it with the person, you can contact a guardian, school, church, or official local support organization together about other assistance. Before making the connection, explain what you would share and with whom, and ask for consent.

Do not diagnose an illness or mental health condition from appearance alone. Medical judgments belong to professionals. In an emergency, such as an immediate risk of injury, do not try to solve the situation by yourself. Ask a responsible adult nearby or a local emergency support service for help. Specific reporting procedures differ by location and situation.

The other person's choices remain their own after you help

Receiving help does not create an obligation to become friends with the helper, attend church, or follow advice. The person must also be free to decline evangelism or an invitation, and conditions must not be added later to help that was already promised. If the person does not want further contact, stop.

You can ask someone who comes to mind today how they are doing without pressing for an answer. If they say they need help, mention one thing you can do and one thing you cannot manage. Focus on respecting the help the person wants instead of trying to change them to fit your wishes.

A Plan for Helping While Respecting Others' Choices

Do not write down anyone's actual personal circumstances. Think only about how you might offer help.

What you enter is not sent to a server. If you save it, it will remain in this browser and be loaded automatically on your next visit. Content you copy or download may remain on your clipboard or in files. On a shared device, do not save, copy, or download your entries. Do not enter your real name, contact details, health information, personal confessions, or details of harm you have experienced.

How can you find out whether the other person needs and wants help?

If the person agrees, what small amount of help can you reasonably provide?

What would you do if the situation were too much to handle alone or your offer were declined?

When thinking about or offering help, did you fully respect the other person's choices?

Notes

  • Do not apply the parable in Luke 10 directly as a modern procedure for first aid or medical judgment.
  • When helping, respect the other person's consent and choices. Do not disclose a name, photograph, or personal circumstances without permission.

References

Scope of application
This article does not replace medical, legal, or emergency judgment for an individual situation or the selection of appropriate local support services.