Does the statement 'the soul remains after a person dies' mean the same thing as 'the resurrection of the body' in the Apostles' Creed? One asks what continues to exist after death. The other asks what Christians believe will finally happen to the dead.
Key point The immortality of the soul and bodily resurrection should be distinguished, though some Christian confessions explain them in connection with each other. The Westminster Confession included by the Presbyterian Church of Korea (TongHap) treats the state of the soul after death separately from the resurrection of the body on the last day. This is the teaching of that Presbyterian tradition, and not every church gives the same detailed interpretation.
What to remember
- The Apostles' Creed and 1 Corinthians 15 confess that final hope includes bodily resurrection.
- The claim that the soul continues to exist after death and the confession that a person will live again with a body answer different questions.
- As you read, distinguish the state immediately after death from resurrection on the last day, and consider whether an interpretation treats the body as merely a shell to be discarded.
How do the Apostles’ Creed and the Bible describe bodily resurrection?
The Apostles’ Creed in the Presbyterian Church of Korea (TongHap) constitution confesses bodily resurrection and eternal life after forgiveness of sins. The Westminster Confession in the same constitution also explains that on the last day the dead will rise and body and soul will be one again. In this Protestant confession, final hope does not end with a disembodied soul.
1 Corinthians 15 also compares the resurrection of the dead to a seed and a new body. Paul does not write that the current body returns unchanged. Yet he also does not make a bodiless soul the final state.
Distinguish the state after death from the final resurrection
'Does the soul continue to exist?' asks whether the soul remains after death. 'What is bodily resurrection?' asks about the belief that God will raise the dead. Saying that the soul remains therefore does not by itself explain bodily resurrection.
When comparing the two explanations, distinguish their points in time as well. First ask whether a statement concerns the state after death or the fulfillment on the last day. Another important difference is that, in traditions that confess bodily resurrection, the body is not merely a shell that will ultimately become unnecessary.
The Presbyterian confession distinguishes the state after death from the last day.
Chapter 32 of the Westminster Confession in the Presbyterian Church of Korea (TongHap) states that the souls of the righteous wait before God for the redemption of their bodies, while the souls of the wicked wait in hell for final judgment. On the last day, the bodies of all the dead rise and become one with their souls again, and the righteous enter glory while the wicked face judgment. It does not say that all people have the same state or outcome after death. This is the explanation in this Presbyterian confession and does not represent every Protestant denomination’s detailed interpretation.
Ways of explaining the soul developed through history.
Theologian Nancey Murphy argues that early Christians, in dialogue with Greek and Roman philosophy, adopted ways of speaking about body and soul. As a result, she says an explanation linking the soul’s persistence and a final bodily resurrection came to be widely established.
This is one theologian’s interpretation of history. To examine the confession and biblical language themselves, compare the Apostles’ Creed, 1 Corinthians 15, and your church’s official doctrinal documents.
Distinguishing Statements About Death and Resurrection
Consider which point in time and which subject each statement you read refers to.
What you enter is not sent to a server. If you save it, it will remain in this browser and be loaded automatically on your next visit. Content you copy or download may remain on your clipboard or in files. On a shared device, do not save, copy, or download your entries. Do not enter your real name, contact details, health information, personal confessions, or details of harm you have experienced.
Summarize the explanation of the soul's state after death.
Separately write down the explanation of the resurrection of the body on the last day.
Would you like to know which parts belong to a denomination's confession of faith and which are interpretations offered by scholars?
After separating the two explanations, have the expressions you still find difficult to understand changed?
Notes
- Denominations and theologians differ in how they explain the similarities and differences between the resurrected body and the present body.
- This article does not address attempts to prove or disprove scientifically whether existence continues after death.
References
- Scope of application
- This article does not compare every philosophical and theological view of the relationship between body and soul.